Discover the Ninja Creami’s “anything goes” magic with creative recipes and ideas — from tinned fruit to protein shakes, puddings and quick no-recipe desserts.

Ninja Creami – The Ice Cream Maker That Breaks All the Rules

As someone who has spent years whisking custards, tempering creams, coaxing air into bases and slowly churning them into silky perfection — the Ninja Creami still baffles me.

It goes against everything I know about how ice cream should be made.

No churn?
No air incorporated?
No gradual freezing?
Just… freeze a block solid and shave it into something creamy?

By all logic, it shouldn’t work.
And yet — it does.

Beautifully.

And that’s exactly why the “anything goes” trend has taken off.

People all over TikTok, Instagram and YouTube are freezing whatever they fancy, popping it into the Creami, pressing a button, and somehow ending up with sorbet, soft serve or something oddly delicious.

As a traditionalist, I should protest.

But as someone who put tinned rhubarb and a squeeze of honey into the Creami — and watched it transform into a velvety, tangy, wonderfully creamy ice cream — I’ve decided we might as well embrace the magic.

If you’re ready to experiment, this guide is going to be your new best friend.

✅ In This Article You’ll Find:

• How the “anything goes” Creami trend started
• What actually works (and what really doesn’t)
• How to use tinned fruit for foolproof frozen desserts
• Fresh vs tinned fruit: when to choose which
• Quick no-recipe Creami ideas
• High-protein & healthier base suggestions
• Indulgent “treat night” ideas
• Common mistakes & how to avoid them
• Mini recipe inspiration
• FAQs
• And plenty of expert tips along the way

The Viral “Anything Goes” Trend — And Why It Works

When the Ninja Creami first hit the scene, people did what people always do with shiny new gadgets:

They pushed it to its limits.

Canned peaches? —> Spin it.
Protein shake? —> Spin it.
Tinned fruit salad? —>Spin it.
Leftover yoghurt, custard, cold brew, tinned lychees, even puddings? —> Spin it all.

The reason this works is simple:

The Creami doesn’t churn — it shaves.

It drills through the frozen block, micro-shaving it into tiny particles and blending them into a creamy texture.

That means:

• pre-cooked fruits behave beautifully
• creamy liquids become soft serve
• puddings turn into thick, scoopable desserts
• you don’t need to worry about ice crystals forming the “traditional” way

It’s not classic ice cream-making — but it is incredibly clever.

Tinned Fruit – The Surprisingly Powerful Ninja Creami Shortcut

Tinned fruit often gets ignored, but it’s secretly one of the best bases for Ninja Creami sorbets and ice creams. It’s affordable, soft, already sweetened, consistent, and ready to use.

And in the Creami?

It becomes silky, bright and full of flavour.

My Own Revelation

Last September, fresh rhubarb was out of season, and I was craving a rhubarb ice cream. So I tried a tin of rhubarb with a squeeze of honey. I was sceptical — but honestly?

It was gorgeous!
Bright, mellow, creamy and absolutely zero effort!
Fresh rhubarb needs cooking… tinned rhubarb doesn’t.

This is where tinned fruit truly shines.

🥭 When to Use Fresh vs Tinned Fruit

Use fresh fruit when:

• it’s in season
• you want full flavour control
• you want visible chunks or ripple swirls
• texture matters (e.g., strawberries folded into a churned custard)

Use tinned fruit when:

• fresh fruit isn’t in season
• you want a quick shortcut
• you’re making blended bases
• you want consistent flavour
• you’re using high-water fruits (peach, pineapple, lychee)
• you want sorbet in minutes

💡 Tinned fruit is often harvested at peak ripeness — and can sometimes outperform off-season fresh fruit.

🍍 How to Prep Tinned Fruit for Creami Success

• Drain the syrup if it’s very thick or overly sweet
• Keep some syrup for sorbets
• Taste before freezing — adjust with lemon juice or a pinch of salt
• Blend until smooth for sorbets
• Add cream, yoghurt or coconut cream for richer scoops
• Freeze flat and level (always!)
• Spin → re-spin → enjoy

🍓 Tinned Fruit Flavour Ideas That Work Beautifully

• Mango + coconut cream
• Pineapple + lime zest
• Peach + Greek yoghurt
• Pear + vanilla + almond butter
• Cherries + dark chocolate chips
• Rhubarb + raspberry + orange zest

💡 Use leftover syrup as a ready-made sugar syrup substitute for sorbets.

What Else Works in the Ninja Creami? Answer – A Lot!

Here’s where the fun really begins.
Below are the categories that truly work — and why.

🥛 1. Protein Shakes (High-Protein Ice Cream)

This is a full viral category on its own.

• Just freeze your shake → spin → re-spin.

Mix-ins like chocolate chips, raspberries or peanut butter are excellent.

🍮 2. Puddings & Custards

The Creami LOVES creamy bases:

• ready-made custard
• chocolate pudding
• caramel or butterscotch pots
• Greek yoghurt
• rice pudding
• trifle custard
• vanilla dessert pots

Creamy bases = luscious, silky results.

☕ 3. Coffee & Drinks

Yes — drinks work too.

Try freezing:

• iced coffee
• frappé mixes
• chocolate milk
• chai latte
• matcha latte
• hot chocolate
• ready-made milkshakes

They turn into soft-serve-style scoops.

🥥 4. Canned Coconut Cream

Chilled overnight → solid part only → freeze → spin.
Add mango or pineapple for an instant tropical dessert.

🍫 5. Indulgent “Treat Night” Ideas

These always work:

• Biscoff latte
• Chocolate oat milk
• Hot chocolate + marshmallows (mix-in!)
• White chocolate milk
• Salted caramel creamer + milk
• Baileys (small amount for adults)

🚫 6. What Doesn’t Work (And Why)

We did say “anything goes”… but not quite anything.

As versatile as the Creami is, there are a few ingredients that simply won’t play ball — here’s what to avoid and why.

• Ice cubes (too hard)
• Frozen solid fruit chunks (too dense)
• Thick nut butters (need diluting)
• Anything over the max-fill line
• Anything oily (separates when shaved)
• Carbonated drinks (pressure issues)

Mini No-Recipe Creami Ideas (Your New Go-To List)

And because the Creami really does shine with the simplest ingredients, here are four mini “no-recipe recipes” you can freeze tonight and enjoy tomorrow — effortless and seriously tasty.

🍑 1. Tinned Peach FroYo

• 1 tin peaches (drained)
• 4 tbsp Greek yoghurt
• 1 tsp honey
  Freeze → spin → re-spin

🥭 2. Mango Sorbet (Vegan)

• 1 tin mango
• 1 tsp lime juice
  Freeze → spin

🍍3. Pineapple Creami

• 1 tin pineapple
• Splash coconut milk
  Freeze → spin

🍌 4. Banana PB Ice Cream

• 2 bananas
• 1 tbsp smooth PB
• Splash milk
  Freeze → spin → re-spin

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Do I always need to re-spin?

Most of the time — yes.
The first spin is essentially the shaving stage: the paddle drills through the solid block and breaks it into tiny frozen particles. It’s smooth-ish, but not truly creamy yet.
The Re-Spin is where the magic happens.
It reprocesses those tiny particles, blending them together into that soft-serve, silky, scoopable texture everyone loves.

Some mixtures (like creamy puddings or high-fat bases) come together beautifully in a single spin. But fruit-heavy, high-water or lighter bases nearly always benefit from a second spin.
If your tub looks crumbly or powdery after the first spin → definitely re-spin.

---

Q: Can I add alcohol?

Yes — in very small amounts.
Around 1–2 tablespoons of alcohol helps improve texture because it lowers the freezing point, which keeps the mixture softer and easier to spin.
But add too much, and the base won’t freeze properly and will stay slushy.
Vodka works best for neutral flavour; rum is great with tropical fruit; Baileys works beautifully in creamy mixes.

---

Q: Can I freeze any canned fruit?

Almost all of them work brilliantly: peaches, pineapple, pears, lychee, mango, rhubarb, cherries — even fruit cocktail.
Because canned fruit is pre-softened and sweetened, it spins into a very smooth texture.

Just remember:

• Drain thick syrup if it’s overly sweet
• Leave a little syrup in if you’re making sorbet
• Add a squeeze of lemon if the fruit tastes flat
• Blend before freezing for best results

---

Q: Why does my ice cream crumble?

The two biggest causes are:

1. The tub wasn’t frozen level — if it freezes at an angle, the blade can’t shave evenly.
2. The base contains too much water — especially if using fruit, milk alternatives or watery drinks.

Fix:

• Give it a Re-Spin
• If it still looks powdery, add 1–2 tbsp milk/cream and re-spin again
• Always freeze tubs perfectly flat
• Chill high-water fruits before freezing and blend well

---

Q: Can I add chunks?

Absolutely — but only after the first spin.
During the initial cycle, the blade blitzes anything you add.

For proper chunks and texture:

• Spin the base first
• Make a small well in the centre with a spoon
• Add your chocolate chips, nuts, fruit, biscuits, etc
• Press the Mix-Ins button

This gently folds the extras through without pulverising them.

🔗 Related Reads You’ll Love

👉🏽 Ninja Creami – A Detailed Review: Thinking of buying one? Our in-depth guide walks you through how it works, what’s changed for 2025, the quirks nobody tells you about, and whether it truly earns its place on your countertop.

👉🏽 Ninja Creami Hacks & Tips – How To Get The Best Results: From fixing crumbly textures to levelling tubs and mastering the re-spin, this guide shows you exactly how to get silky, scoopable results every single time — with loads of flavour ideas too.

👉🏽 Ninja Swirl Vs Ninja Creami – Which Ice Cream Maker Is Worth It In 2025?
Soft-serve lover or classic scoop fan? This comparison breaks down the differences, the pros and cons, and which machine suits your dessert style (and kitchen space!) best.

The Final Scoop

The Ninja Creami might not follow classic ice cream rules — no slow churn, no careful incorporation of air — but the results speak for themselves.

It’s clever, fun, wildly versatile, and perfect for experimenting. Whether you’re freezing a tin of peaches, a protein shake, leftover custard, or your favourite latte, the Creami transforms everyday ingredients into something creamy, cold, and completely delicious.

And yes — even a tin of rhubarb with a squeeze of honey becomes an incredibly easy, scoop-worthy, delicious dessert.

We hope you’ve enjoyed our guide — Ninja Creami – Anything Goes Recipes & Ideas — and that it’s inspired you to try a few new combinations of your own.

If you have any questions, flavour ideas, or want to share your latest Creami creation, pop a comment below — we always love hearing from you.

Stay connected for more homemade ice cream inspiration!

Share your frozen creations with us on social media and join a community of dessert lovers. Follow Frosted Fusions on Pinterest, Instagram, Facebook, and X — just click the icons below.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our website and allows us to continue creating content. Thank you for your support!