How To Make Custard-Style Ice Cream Silky, Smooth & Fool Proof

Learn how to make silky, smooth custard-style ice cream with this fool proof guide. Avoid curdling, master tempering, and get perfect texture every time!

If you’re ready to take your homemade ice cream up a notch, custard-style is where the magic happens. It’s rich, silky, and delivers that smooth texture and depth of flavour that just can’t be matched by simpler bases.

Making it, though? That’s where a lot of home cooks hesitate. If you’ve ever worried about cooking eggs, tempering milk, or curdling the whole thing, you’re not alone.

These are common hesitations for home cooks, and this guide is designed to walk you through it, step by step, without the fuss.

With the right method (and a little confidence), it’s much more straightforward than it seems. Once you get the hang of it — low heat, steady stirring, and knowing when to stop — you’ll never look back. And the results? Totally worth it.

✅ In This Article:

• What custard-style ice cream actually is (and how it differs from Philly-style)
• How to temper eggs without scrambling them
• The key signs your custard is perfectly cooked
• What to do if it starts to curdle
• A flexible custard base recipe + variations
• How to store custard-style ice cream
• FAQs + final tips for silky smooth success

What is Custard-Style Ice Cream?

Custard-style (also called “French-style”) ice cream is made with an egg yolk–based custard, gently cooked on the stovetop before chilling and churning. The yolks thicken the mixture and give the final product a rich, scoopable texture that’s noticeably creamier than Philadelphia-style (eggless) ice cream.

The main ingredients?

• Whole milk
• Double cream
• Egg yolks
• Sugar
• Optional flavourings (like vanilla, chocolate, spices, infusions)

Philly-style (short for Philadelphia-style) is quicker to make because it skips the eggs entirely — it’s simply cream, milk, sugar, and flavourings, no cooking required.

That means it’s great for quick batches or those avoiding eggs, and it still produces a light, refreshing scoop. But it doesn’t have the same velvety depth or “melt-in-the-mouth” feel that custard-style offers — especially when it comes to more indulgent flavours like chocolate or coffee.

📝 We’ll be explaining Philly-style ice cream in a dedicated article soon — including when to choose it, how to tweak the texture, and why it shines for some flavours.

Why Make Custard Ice Cream?

If you’ve only ever made quick no-churn or Philly-style ice creams, custard might just be your next big leap. Why? Because it creates that full-bodied, scooping texture that’s hard to beat.

🔹 Texture: It’s ultra-creamy, with a dense mouthfeel and great scoopability.
🔹 Flavour: Egg yolks carry flavour beautifully — your vanilla will taste deeper, chocolate richer, and add-ins more balanced.
🔹 Structure: Custard bases hold their shape longer when scooped and melt more evenly.

Ingredients & Ratios – The Custard-Style Formula

The following table provides your base ratio guide for making a classic custard ice cream, easily adaptable for any flavour.

Ingredient	Amount	Notes
Whole Milk	500ml	Adds lightness and helps blend the fat content
Double Cream	250ml	High-fat content for smoothness (UK alternative to “heavy cream”)
Egg Yolks	6 large	Thickens and emulsifies the base
Caster Sugar	150g	Adjust to taste depending on add-ins
Vanilla	1 tsp extract or ½ vanilla pod	Optional, or swap for your preferred flavour

💡 Did You Know?
Egg yolks don’t just thicken — they emulsify fat and water, creating the smooth, creamy mouthfeel that custard-style is known for.

Making Custard Ice Cream (Without Curdling)

This is where the technique matters — and once you get it, it’s simple and repeatable.

Here’s how to do it with confidence;

1️⃣ Heat the Milk + Cream: Warm gently in a heavy-based pan until steaming (but not boiling). Add your vanilla if using a pod.

2️⃣ Whisk Egg Yolks + Sugar: In a separate bowl, whisk until the mixture turns pale and fluffy.

3️⃣ Tempering Eggs — The Gentle Way

This step tends to intimidate beginners, but it’s simpler than it sounds — and once you’ve done it once, you’ll feel far more confident.

Tempering means gradually warming the eggs so they don’t scramble. You do this by whisking warm (but not boiling) milk or cream into the yolks in a slow, steady stream — just enough to gently raise their temperature.

Once tempered, the egg mixture can safely be returned to the saucepan for thickening — no scrambled eggs in sight.

💡 Confidence Tip:
Take your time. Use a ladle to add the warm milk mixture little by little, whisking continuously. You’ll start to feel when the eggs are warming without cooking. Trust the process — it’s the key to that luscious, custard-style texture.

4️⃣ Cook Until It Thickens
Return everything to the pan over low heat. Stir constantly with a wooden spoon or silicone spatula.

Look for:
✔ A coating on the back of a spoon
✔ A clean line drawn through it with your finger
✔ (Optional: use a thermometer — 76–82°C / 170–180°F)

⚠️ Don’t let it boil! That’s when curdling kicks in.

❗ What To Do If It Starts To Curdle

💡 Oh no — it’s splitting! What now?

Don’t panic. If you see signs of curdling:

• Remove from heat immediately
• Pour into a blender and blitz until smooth
• Strain through a fine sieve

This won’t always fix a badly scrambled batch, but it can rescue minor curdling and still give you a usable base.

If it smooths out well and still tastes good, you can go ahead and churn it. The texture might be slightly less silky than perfect batches — but still totally scoop-worthy.

5️⃣ Strain and chill

Strain the custard through a fine mesh sieve into a clean bowl to remove any stray bits of egg or pod. Let it cool slightly, then cover and chill for at least 4 hours, preferably overnight.

❄️ Churning & Storage

Once the custard has fully chilled (4–12 hours), churn in your ice cream maker per the instructions. It will turn into a rich, soft-serve consistency.

Transfer to a pre-chilled container, smooth the top, and freeze for at least 4 hours.

💡 Did You Know?
Ice cream often improves in texture after 24 hours — flavours meld, and becomes more scoopable.

No Ice Cream Maker? No Problem.

You can still enjoy custard-style ice cream with a no-churn method:

1. After chilling your custard base, pour it into a shallow freezer-safe dish.
2. Freeze for 45–60 minutes.
3. Stir vigorously with a fork or whisk to break up ice crystals.
4. Repeat every 30 minutes until smooth and scoopable (3–4 hours total).

Not quite the same as machine-churned — but still deliciously creamy.

An Easy Classic Vanilla Bean Custard Ice Cream Starter Recipe

Now that you’ve got the method down, here’s a simple starter recipe to practise with — rich, scoopable, and easy to customise with your favourite flavours.

Ingredients

• 500ml whole milk
• 250ml double cream
• 6 egg yolks
• 150g caster sugar
• 1 vanilla bean pod (or 1.5 tsp good extract)
• Pinch of salt

Method

1. Heat milk + cream + vanilla in a saucepan
2. Whisk yolks + sugar separately
3. Temper yolks with warm milk
4. Return to the pan and cook over low heat until thickened
5. Strain, chill 4–12 hrs
6. Churn, freeze, enjoy

Serving Suggestion:

Keep it classic — or try out different ways to dress it up with toppings, swirls, or a creative twist. Pair with stewed fruit or an espresso drizzle for an affogato-style twist.

Flavour Variations

Now you’ve mastered the custard base, now you can adapt it to your hearts content. There are endless flavour variations to try.

Here are just a few ideas:

• Vanilla Bean: Steep the pod in the milk, remove before tempering.
• Salted Caramel: Replace 75g sugar with 100g homemade caramel.
• Lavender Honey: Infuse milk with dried lavender, and replace half the sugar with honey.
• Dark Chocolate: Add 150g chopped chocolate once the custard is cooked — whisk until smooth.

Can You Make Custard Ice Cream Dairy-Free?

Yes — with some adaptations. Egg yolks can be used to stabilise non-dairy milks too, but you’ll need to add fat (like coconut cream or nut butter) for creaminess.

Try this ratio:

• 400ml oat or almond milk
• 150ml coconut cream
• 5 egg yolks
• 100g sugar
• 1 tbsp cashew butter (optional, for richness)

Troubleshooting – Common Mistakes

The Final Scoop

Custard-style ice cream takes a bit more time, but the payoff is incredible texture and flavour. Once you’ve made one batch, you’ll feel more confident – slow heat, steady whisk, gentle chill — and soon you’ll be whipping up flavours from pistachio to passionfruit with confidence.

Don’t fear the eggs — master them! And if your first batch scrambles? Don’t worry, we’ve all been there. Try again. Your next scoop might just be your best yet.

We hope that you have enjoyed our article – How To Make Custard-Style Ice Cream Silky, Smooth & Fool Proof – and that we’ve inspired you to give this rich, silky-smooth recipe a try.

Whether it’s your first time tempering eggs or you’re refining your technique, we’re here to help make the process feel approachable and rewarding. If you have any questions, please drop us a comment below — we’ll be happy to get back to you.

Stay connected for more homemade ice cream inspiration! Share your ice cream creations with us on social media, and connect with a community of fellow frozen treat enthusiasts. Join us for mouthwatering recipes, expert tips, and exclusive updates. Follow us on Pinterest, Instagram, Facebook, and X by clicking on any of the social media icons below.

Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you click on these links and make a purchase, we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. This helps support our website and allows us to continue creating content. Thank you for your support!